Black's valuable center pawn is threatened with capture, but White's pawn remains safe.
The question for Black at this point is whether to challenge the White pawn on e4 or support the Black one on e5.
2... Nc6 is the natural move, combining defence of the pawn with control of the d4 square and avoiding committing another pawn for now.
2. Nf3 is 10 times more popular than everything else combined, and in turn the reply 2... Nc6 is about 5 times more popular than everything else combined.
2... d6, Philidor's Defence, is the other safe option to defend the pawn.
It restricts the f8 bishop to the e7 square, and grants White an advantage in territory, but it builds a fortress that cannot be easily battered down.
An alternative (older) way to play this is to follow up with 3... f5.
Note that 2... f6? is a bad move.
It has a name, Damiano's Defence, but poor Damiano never wanted his name associated with it because it doesn't work White captures the pawn anyway.
2... Nf6 is the Petrov Defence.
Black wants the same things that White wants, but once again White will be back in a symmetrical position with the advantage of moving first.
2... f5 is the Latvian Gambit.
This iconic counter-thrust divides opinion like very few other openings.
Has Black lured White into a minefield of tricks and traps leading to an inevitable violent death?
Or has Black given away a pawn for nothing?
2... d5 is the Elephant Gambit.
It's along the same lines as the Latvian, but less complex White needs to do less memorising to reach a good position.
Game | Result | Year |
Caruana, F. (2818) vs Carlsen, M. (2882) | 1-0 | 2019 |
Carlsen, M. (2882) vs Caruana, F. (2818) | 1/2-1/2 | 2019 |
Caruana, Fabiano (2835) vs Carlsen, Magnus (2863) | 0-1 | 2020 |
Carlsen, Magnus (2863) vs Caruana, Fabiano (2835) | 1-0 | 2020 |
Carlsen, Magnus (2863) vs Caruana, Fabiano (2835) | 1-0 | 2020 |
Carlsen, Magnus (2863) vs Caruana, Fabiano (2835) | 1/2-1/2 | 2020 |
Caruana, Fabiano (2835) vs Carlsen, Magnus (2863) | 1/2-1/2 | 2020 |
Caruana, Fabiano (2835) vs Carlsen, Magnus (2863) | 1/2-1/2 | 2020 |
Caruana, F. (2819) vs Carlsen, M. (2875) | 1/2-1/2 | 2019 |
Carlsen, M. (2882) vs Ding Liren (2805) | 0-1 | 2019 |